What is An Appropriate Age Spread for Dating?

by Tobe Hitch on October 15, 2009

I believe that the maximum age spread is: guy is 8 years older, or girl is 2 years older.  I know that immediately, especially when it comes to the girl only being 2 years older I’m going to have a lot of raised eyebrows.  Give me an opportunity to explain myself!

First and foremost, the 8 year spread comes with a PREREQUISITE.  The girl MUST be at least 21 years old.  That means that going from 20 (guy age) and 12 (girl age) OBVIOUSLY DOES NOT WORK.  As a matter of fact, that is just sick, and I would kung fu your ass if I ever found out about it.  Unless you are some super buff, athletic 20 year old.  In which case, I would disapprove and judge from afar.  Very afar.

Hah.  I showed you suckah.

But, even in a less extreme example, going from 24-16 is not acceptable.  Not only could that get you into serious trouble (if you have sex it becomes statutory RAPE), but it’s just disturbing and gross on so many levels.  Sort of how 20+ years older with a kid that is your age is gross and disturbing on SOO many levels.

Another thing that I do not support is senior-freshman in high school (which would be roughly 18-14).  Even though that is a 4 year spread, that’s still a risk for statutory as well, and apart from that, SHE JUST GOT OUT OF MIDDLE SCHOOL.  There’s really something wrong with that.  Furthermore, when both parties are so young (pre-college) there is still so much maturing and growing that needs to happen.

NOW, once you hit college, however, I think there’s a “progressively” expanding dating spread that occurs.  At first, when you are a freshman, I think that if you have a girlfriend from high school who is one year younger (or visa versa for the girl), then it’s definitely fine to stay in that relationship.  Honestly, my personal opinion is, “don’t kid yourself, your relationship isn’t going to work”, though.  I remember my first year of college, there were SOOO MANY couples that tried to stay together after one of them graduated and the other stayed behind in high school.   HAHAHA.  I’m not trying to be a jerk, but it was funny watching each of those relationships getting picked off one by one.  The first month, you could hear all the conversations outside in the dorm hallway between the guy and the girl, obviously arguing about “you went out and you didn’t tell me about it!  OMG”.  Second month, GG.  Game over.  Relationships ending by the dozens!  Girls and guys both crying in the hallways.  It was…really sad.

Okay okay, I’m not trying to be a jerk and enjoy the fact that a bunch of these “once one of them entered college” relationships failed, and I do know that there are the RARE gems that seem to work through even these hardships, but I think I have a deep bitter jadedness toward this because when I entered college both of the girls that I wanted to date (from my dorm) were dating someone from high school.  DAH!  It was so sad.  I got out-gamed by a high school senior.  That is…until 2 months in…

ANYWAYS, when you enter college, the age spread increases as follows for guys, and the girls side stays consistent (2 years down, X years up):

  1. Freshman Year (18-19 Years Old): 1 year younger (you must have been dating before you entered college) and 2 years older (although if you get a junior as a freshman, STUD!)
  2. Second Year (19-20 years old): 1 year younger (You cannot dip back into high school anymore you disgusting..) and 2 years older (although, once again, if you can get a senior as a sophomore, STUD!!!)
  3. Third Year (20-21 years old): 2 years younger (Although, you should wait for the end of freshman year to give the girl some time to mature) and 2 years older (ONCE AGAIN!  GRADUATE!?  STUD!!!)
  4. Fourth Year (21-22 years old): 2 years younger (You better not be dipping back into freshman…they’re basically HIGH SCHOOLERS until after they finish their first year…) and 2 years older (not as much of the stud as the top three situations, but still!  STUDLY my friend)
  5. First Year out of College (22-23 years old): 3 years younger (Although, that third year is stretching it…it’s not as bad imo) and 2 years older (now you do not get the “stud” label since you graduated, and she’s graduated).
  6. Second Year out of College (23-24 years old): 3 years younger, 2 years older
  7. Third Year out of College (24-25): 4 years younger (by now, even if you dipped back into college the girl should be a senior and therefore I believe mature enough to handle a serious relationship), 2 years older

You guys should get the idea now.  The cap is obviously 8 years younger and 2 years older.  I personally believe that once a girl is a senior in college, it’s fair game (up until you’re 8 years older as a guy).  My reasoning for this is because I believe that if you ever start dating the girl, you can date for 1 year (while she’s in school), and then once she graduates, start getting ready for marriage.  In my opinion, 1 year is all you need to “date” to figure out if it makes sense.  I think you go through all the “seasons” of a relationship during a 1 year period, and usually 1 year of dating is followed by 1 year of engagement.

I want to clarify here that this is the CAP, and not the norm.  I don’t think it’s NORMAL for girls who are 8 years younger to date guys who are 8 years older.  But, if it had to happen, I think anymore than this is ridiculous.  OBVIOUSLY, if you can keep the age gap closer, that would be ideal.  I think for me, the “IDEAL” is a 2-4 year spread.

Now, this is where I give my reasons why I accept this age spread.  I believe that a guy should be older than the girl he dates, generally.  Now I know that that’s not a “set rule”, and nowadays you get the Demi Moore and Aston Kutcher coupling that DEFIES all regular logic.  However, I think it’s just practical for a guy to be older.  The reasons why I believe this go back to, what in essence, makes a guy “go” and what makes a woman “go”.  These ideas are primarily found in the book You Just Don’t Understand by Deborah Tannen.  I’m paraphrasing and summarizing like mad here, but I think her ultimate position is that guys desire for respect (one up each other), and girls desire to be loved (have community).  I think most of us can agree that this is a true statement to a certain extent…and it doesn’t mean that guys don’t want to be loved, and girls don’t want to be respected.  What it means is that when it REALLY boils down to it, what gets us going (guys) is a desire/thirst for respect and success, whereas for girls, there is a much deeper imbedded community/love aspect.  It’s easier to love on a girl (especially if your love language is GIFTS) when you’re older and have more money, and it’s easier to respect a guy if the guy is older than you and has more experience, knowledge, and wisdom in life.

There are always exceptions to the rule, but on the norm, I think that this is a true statement.  Within that regard, when the girl is older, it’s generally harder for the girl to respect a guy who’s younger, unless the guy is REALLY mature and has everything together.  This is because with age comes more experience, wisdom, and understanding.  So I think that’s why it’s generally difficult to go beyond the “girl is 2 years older” spread.  Can it happen?  Sure.  Am I opposed to it?  Not really.  But, I think when we consider these dynamics, it’s hard to go beyond 2 years.

I realize that another thing my “escalating” age gap portrays is the reality that guys (as they get older) increase their pool of potential while girls (as they get older) decrease their pool of potential.  All I gotta say to that is, if you’re a girl and you have a problem with it, BY ALL MEANS date 8 years younger!  I’m ALL about equality here!  Are there any thirty two year olds out there with tons of money, single, and looking for a mature male?

You be my suga momma, and I’ll be your boo.

VOMIT.

{ 1 trackback }

logo college
December 21, 2009 at 2:42 pm

{ 13 comments… read them below or add one }

ilikebeets October 15, 2009 at 1:12 pm

There is rule a good friend of mine told me. Its a mathematical approach. The youngest person you can date is one that is half your age plus 7. I’m 23, so the youngest person I should be dating is 19, which isn’t unreasonable. This also works with the youngens. If you’re 16 the youngest you can date is 15 (16/2 = 8 +7 = 15). This work work the “how young can you go” question. The question on how old you should go, well, I think once you hit a certain age(24-25), age doesn’t matter. Thats my 2 cents on the subject.

[Reply]

yo October 15, 2009 at 1:54 pm

Hey,

I want to see your thoughts of the following:

Interracial relationships (especially within the asian culture).
Are people just meant to be within their own race? You will say no…but wouldn’t it make things much easier to just marry people within own race? Issues such as : your children identity crisis, family traditions, relationship with parents, your whole view on life and the way to raise, food, etc…

Is it worth going to all the trouble and marrying out of your race and technically making your asian parents unhappy?

[Reply]

Pen Name October 15, 2009 at 1:55 pm

I will definitely post on that topic! I’ll post on it this Saturday, as a matter of fact. Thanks for the request, and a great topic idea!

[Reply]

Sarah October 15, 2009 at 2:45 pm

Ok, “dating” is not rape if there aren’t any sexual acts involved so let’s get that straight.

[Reply]

Pen Name October 15, 2009 at 2:46 pm

good point! i will revise my post accordingly.

[Reply]

Sarah October 15, 2009 at 3:07 pm

Basing marriage potential on 1 year of dating while a woman is still in school does nothing to prepare her for the real world where people’s expectations change the moment school is over. I also don’t understand the 1 year engagement, aside from practical reason of planning a wedding, why wait a year? What’s so “christian” about that any of this?

[Reply]

Pen Name October 15, 2009 at 3:38 pm

Hey Sarah,

Thanks for your comment. First, I want to say that I realize that people’s opinion on this subject may vary, and that’s why when I write these posts I’m not really trying to “make it a fact”. They are my opinions, and all my readers are free to have their own opinions just as I am free to have mine. Like I said, I’m more writing for fun than for knowledge. I realize that when you write on controversial topics, people are going to have some pretty hardcore stances on specific topics. That’s all good.

However, to address your specific questions, I believe that (although life definitely changes after graduation), you are mostly mature by the time you are 21, and if you have a guy who is older, they can actually provide a LOT of stability during your post graduate life.

In response to your second question, the 1 year engagement is for (exactly what you said) the practical aspect of planning a marriage. Furthermore, I also think that that one year is different from the time when you date because your mindset in the relationship completely changes. Marriage is obviously a big deal! Having one year to make sure that you’re secure in the relationship (after the proposal) I think is very beneficial for both parties. The exact time is negligible, it can be shorter, but I say take some time to think about it and make sure you definitely want it!

Finally, I’m not really proposing “christian” ideas of dating completely. Sometimes they are a little bit more focused, other times they are not. This is just my overall opinion of what an acceptable age spread is! Thanks, and take care!

[Reply]

Sarah October 15, 2009 at 5:36 pm

Thanks for the clarification. BTW if you’re going to cougar bait just remember that your 20-something heinie is competing with high school boys…better start looking into botox and collagen ;)

[Reply]

Rebeca October 15, 2009 at 5:52 pm

Ha ha ha, this site is great! I like to read all the things you write is funny and intelligent at the same time.
A few time ago I was dating to my ex BF he was 27 and I was 19 in the beginning, and I had a lot of fun with him in fact I left him (he wanted to marry me but I don’t… ehem : P ) at my 22 and his 30 years old right now, I don’t think that I could date someone younger than me, I’m used to be with older men and I like it : )

Please don’t stop writing you do it well.

[Reply]

Cougar October 15, 2009 at 10:53 pm

*ring ring*

[Reply]

JOhn Riley October 15, 2009 at 11:32 pm

I’m actually very interested in reading that future post on inter-racial relationships, as I am the product of one such relationship.

[Reply]

coffeedrinker October 16, 2009 at 12:22 am

Divide by 2 plus 7! I think that’s a much more logical and practical approach than having to look for someone who is only 1 year younger and so forth. I’m not saying there shouldn’t be any discernment in choosing who to date either… but if a guy is 24 and the girl is 19, they get along great and everything, then it’s all good!

[Reply]

Pen Name October 17, 2009 at 4:40 pm

I will be posting about interracial dating on tuesday! Sorry, I tried to sneak it in today (Saturday) but I’m really really busy these days. Tues-Thurs will continue to be my post days! Take care!

[Reply]

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: